Poking around inside cars and Legions is necessary

National Post
Sat 06 Nov 2004

Re: Taking The War On Tobacco Too Far, Nov. 4.

Adam Radwanski complains that the potential regulation of second-hand smoke exposure in cars transporting children and Legion branches is excessive. I doubt that he also believes seatbelt requirements or regulations concerning the size and function of child seats in cars -- regulations which amount to "poking around inside our cars" -- should be abandoned. All focus on protecting health, often that of our most vulnerable population.

Concerning the Legion, while everyone honours and respects the courage and sacrifices of our Armed Forces' veterans, the Legion today is a different place than it was after the Second World War. As Legion officials themselves have noted publicly, anyone can now join the club.

In some municipalities where smoke-free bylaws have been debated, I have heard local bar owners object strongly to smoking exemptions for the Legions, as they are direct competition.

One of the many promised benefits of the provincial smoke-free legislation is that it would provide a level playing field for all owners, patrons and workers alike in public places. It's no surprise some establishments will try to circumvent smoke-free regulations by claiming a unique status they do not in fact have, in this context.

Michael Perley
director
Ontario Campaign for Action on Tobacco